Categories: News

Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Mike Postle And Stone’s Gambling Hall

On Wednesday afternoon, a U.S. District judge dismissed a federal lawsuit against poker player Mike Postle for allegedly cheating in livestreamed cash games at Stones Gambling Hall.

In his action, Judge William B. Shubb of the Eastern District of California additionally dismissed lawsuits against Stones Gambling Hall and its poker room manager, Justin Kuraitis.

Latest twist in livestreamed poker cheating saga

The dismissals represent the latest twist in a story that has, at times, captivated the poker world’s attention over the last nine months. Postle’s accusers first went public with their claims last September, filing their lawsuit in October.

The lawsuit contained multiple causes of action against each of the defendants. The lawsuit lists more than 80 plaintiffs, with Maryland-based lawyer Maurice “Mac” VerStandig heading the legal team representing them.

All of the plaintiffs are poker players who played in games versus Postle on the “Stones Live Poker” livestream which debuted in January 2018. They have alleged Postle received information about his opponents’ hole cards as he was playing, thereby enabling him to win at statistically improbable rates.

Postle is alleged to have won more than $250,000 in the games, booking victories in 94% of the sessions in which he played during 2018 and 2019. In the lawsuit, plaintiffs collectively sought $30 million in damages from the defendants.

Judge explains dismissal, leaves door open for plaintiffs to amend

In April, the defendants in the case filed motions to dismiss, their filings joined together under the one brought by King’s Casino LLC, operator of Stones Gambling Hall. The causes of action against them covered a variety of different complaints, including negligence, negligent misrepresentation, constructive fraud, fraud, and libel.

In the 24-page ruling, Judge Brill offered various reasons for dismissing the different charges. In some cases, he noted causes of action were being “dismissed with leave to amend” should the plaintiffs be able to provide further evidence to support their claims.

For example, the claim of negligent misrepresentation against King’s Casino (i.e., Stones Gambling Hall) stemmed from the plaintiffs’ position that Stones “created ‘an implicit representation’ that players would be ‘protected from the cheating of other players.’” The plaintiffs maintain Stones was, in fact, aware of Postle’s cheating and that “at least one agent of Stones served as a John Doe or Jane Doe confederate of Mr. Postle.”

However, as Judge Brill explains, the “plaintiffs failed to disclose the identity of the alleged confederate.” He notes that the plaintiffs have indicated a readiness to make such a disclosure and identify the accomplice “by name and position.” Thus has the cause of action been dismissed with leave to amend should the plaintiffs return with additional support for their claim.

VerStandig has already indicated that the case will be amended and brought once again.

Stones Gambling Hall, located in Citrus Heights near Sacramento, has remained closed since mid-March in response to the coronavirus pandemic.

The post Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Mike Postle And Stone’s Gambling Hall appeared first on Play CA.


Published by

Recent Posts

888poker Sunday Sale Offers 50% Off Major Tournament Entries; Turbo Gift Drops Underway

The popular Sunday Sale returns to 888poker’s major tournaments this Sunday, Jan. 24. The site…

3 days ago

BUILDING MOMENTUM: What the Wire Act Ruling Means for the Future of Online Poker

Online poker players received some good news on Tuesday with a federal appeals court ruling…

3 days ago

San Jose City Council Strengthens Support For Cardrooms At Precarious Juncture

It’s an interesting time to run a cardroom in California. At the very least, the…

4 days ago

Connecticut Online Casino Is Part Of New Sports Betting Legislation

Online casino is back on the agenda in Connecticut, alongside sports betting, in new legislation…

4 days ago

NEGREANU-POLK CENTRAL (Day 30): Polk Wins Big in Tweet-Filled Session to Top $1 Million; Next Session Set for Friday

Doug Polk reached his first $1 million mark on Wednesday over  Daniel Negreanu. Polk chalked…

5 days ago

MGM Resorts Abandons Takeover Plans Following Cold Shoulder From Entain: Where Do They Go From Here?

Despite initially hoping to continue negotiations, MGM Resorts International has abandoned its takeover plans following…

5 days ago